How Do You Redesign a Website Without Losing SEO Rankings?

Ammar Sohail 5 min read
How Do You Redesign a Website Without Losing SEO Rankings?
In this post
  1. What actually causes traffic drops after a redesign?
  2. How do you redesign a website without losing SEO before you build anything?
  3. Which redirects do you need, and how long do you keep them?
  4. What should you check on the staging site?
  5. What do you do in the first month after launch?
  6. Next step

You can redesign a website without losing SEO rankings if every old URL that has value points to its new equivalent with a permanent (301) redirect. Do that before launch, keep your page content and titles close to what already ranks, and check Google Search Console afterwards.

Most ranking drops after a redesign aren't caused by the new look. They come from URLs that changed, pages that vanished and a site that was blocked from Google while it was being built.

What actually causes traffic drops after a redesign?

Three things, mostly. Changed URLs with no redirects are the big one, so Google and every old link land on a "page not found" error. Thinner content comes next: a designer trims a long page down to a headline and two buttons, and the page loses the words it ranked for. Last, there's often a leftover "noindex" tag or a blocking robots.txt file copied across from the staging site.

If you only change the design and keep the same URLs, the same text and the same headings, the risk is small. Trouble starts when the structure changes too.

How do you redesign a website without losing SEO before you build anything?

Start with a list of what you have. Export every URL from your current site (a crawler such as Screaming Frog's free version handles up to 500 URLs) and pull your top pages from Google Search Console under Performance. Mark the pages that bring clicks, leads or links.

Then decide what happens to each one:

  • Keep the same URL and improve the page.
  • Move it to a new URL and add a redirect.
  • Merge it into a stronger page and redirect the old one there.
  • Remove it only if it has no traffic and no links.

This sheet becomes your redirect map. Ask your designer or agency to see it before development starts, not after. If you haven't set up reporting yet, do that first so you have a before-and-after picture. We cover it in our guide to setting up Google Analytics 4.

Which redirects do you need, and how long do you keep them?

Use server-side permanent redirects. Google's site move guidance names 301 and 308 as the recommended types and says permanent redirects don't cause a loss in PageRank. Avoid 302s for pages that have moved for good, and don't send every old page to the homepage. Send each one to the closest matching new page.

Google also says to redirect the old homepage and the canonical pages of your old site. On how long to keep them, Google's Change of Address tool page says at least 180 days, and longer if you still see search traffic hitting the old URLs. In practice we'd keep them for a year or more, since a redirect costs nothing to leave in place. You can read the details in Google's guide to moving a site with URL changes.

A small example. Your old page is /services/web-design.html and the new one is /web-design/. You add one 301 rule from the first to the second. On WordPress that's a line in your redirect plugin or server config; on Shopify it's under Content, Navigation, URL Redirects.

What should you check on the staging site?

Staging sites are usually hidden from Google so they don't compete with the live one. That's sensible, but the setting has to come off at launch. Check these before you go live:

  • The "Discourage search engines" box in WordPress (Settings, Reading) is unticked on the live site.
  • No page has a noindex tag you didn't intend. Our post on robots.txt vs noindex explains the difference.
  • Title tags, meta descriptions and h1 headings carried over from the old pages that ranked.
  • Internal links point to the new URLs, not through a chain of redirects.
  • Images keep their alt text, and the new pages load quickly on a phone.

What do you do in the first month after launch?

Submit your sitemap again in Search Console (here's how to submit a sitemap to Google) and open the Pages report to look for new "Not found (404)" entries. Each one is an old URL you missed. Add the redirect and move on.

Expect some wobble. Google has to recrawl your pages, and its move guide says a move is only complete once Googlebot has visited every old and new URL at least once. Rankings can dip for a few weeks and recover. If they're still down after two months, compare your top pages' content before and after, because that's where the cause usually is.

Check your top ten pages by hand each week for the first month. Click the old URLs from your spreadsheet and confirm each lands on the right page in one hop.

Next step

Before you approve any new design, ask for the redirect map and your top ten pages' current titles and headings in writing. If you'd like someone to build that into the project, our SEO optimisation service covers it, and our website development team can handle the rebuild itself. You can also get in touch and send us your URL list.

Common questions

Will my rankings drop after a redesign?

A small dip is normal while Google recrawls the site. A big, lasting drop usually points to missing redirects, removed content or a noindex tag left on from staging.

Should I change my domain name at the same time?

Avoid it if you can. A new domain adds a second move on top of the redesign. Do the redesign first, let rankings settle, then change the domain later if you must, using Google's Change of Address tool.

Can I redirect everything to the homepage to save time?

No. Redirect each old page to its closest new equivalent. Sending everything to the homepage tells Google little and leaves visitors on a page they didn't ask for.

You might also like